Skip to content
Justina MillerNov 15, 2016 12:00:00 AM1 min read

Amy Grant’s Christmas Album Banned from Christian Bookstore

Amy Grant fans have expressed their sympathies after Grant’s latest Christmas album was denied by Christian bookstores. Rather than be upset that her album, entitled “Amy Grant’s Tennessee Christmas,” will be sold at less stores this holiday season, Grant's response is one of love. 

Grant wrote on her Facebook page:

"Let's all move on from that decision without arguing about it. But let's not stop asking the questions about what it means to live in faith and reflect love to the world around us."

According to Christian Examiner, "Amy Grant’s Tennessee Christmas" was declined by LifeWay Christian Stores. The reason is still unknown. Christian Examiner spoke with Lifeway Spokesperson, Marty King, who said, “I wish I had more to share with you, but we don't discuss the reasons we carry the few thousand items we sell nor the reasons we don't carry the hundreds of thousands of products we don't sell.”

Read Also: The 'Hillsong' Movie Gets What Most Bible Movies Miss

Lifeway’s decision begs the question, “What makes music ‘Christian?’” Her album has songs such as “O Come All Ye Faithful” and “Joy to the World." However, it also has songs that are more secular in nature, such as “Christmas Don’t Be Late” and a new tune called “Melancholy Christmas,” which she wrote for those who spend Christmas alone. Christian radio plays Amy Grant and artists such as The Fray or Jon Forman of Switchfoot  who walk the line between Christian and secular music. Do their lyrics that never mention God make their songs Godless?

Whether these crossover artists write directly about Jesus or write good, positive music that the whole family can enjoy, let’s hope they keep making their music and follow Christ’s command to “Let your light so shine before men, that they may see your good works, and glorify your Father which is in heaven.” (Matt 5:16 KJV)

Do you love music? Check out the movie, Divine Will, coming to Pure Flix on Nov. 18. You can watch thousands of family movies, musicals, TV series, and documentaries for free on Pure Flix with a free trial. Click here to sign-up.

Cover Photo Credit: Ga Fullner /


Justina Miller

Justina Miller grew up as a full time musician in a band with her sister. At eighteen she took her creativity to a University setting where she studied poetry at George Mason University and Oxford University in England. After college, Justina worked in campus ministry leadership with FOCUS at Vanderbilt University. There, she mentored students while fundraising her entire salary.

Justina went on to volunteer at an orphanage in India, and came back to the states to run conferences for FOCUS. In 2012, she returned to her musical roots to perform in DC as a jazz singer and maintained freelance writing gigs for columns, copywriting, screenplays, and ghostwriting for a major publication.

Recently, Justina has settled in New York City where she performs in local venues, continues to freelance, and runs crowdfunding, email marketing, and social media management for the Chiaroscuro Foundation.