Great American Christmas Movie Challenge: Rankings Reveal Week #4

By Natalie Zadrima, Programming & Development Content Manager

Welcome back to the third week of the Great American Christmas Movie Challenge Rankings Reveal! 

This weekend we will have two new premieres joining the challenge: The Christmas Yes List and Christmas at Moose Lake. 

In The Christmas Yes List, Danica McKellar stars as Chloe Hollis, a people-pleaser who returns to her hometown for Christmas after a disappointing turn in her professional life. Determined to overcome her fear of rejection, Chloe takes on a challenge to hear no from 10 people before Christmas. But when she meets James, who has his own reasons for embracing the word yes, she discovers that stepping outside her comfort zone can lead to unexpected connections and new beginnings. 

Meanwhile, Christmas at Moose Lake stars Britt Robertson, Ryan Paevey, Kevin Dillon, and Natasha Henstridge in a touching story about love, family, and new beginnings. After a breakup brings Alyssa Dawson back to her family's lake house for Christmas, she finds herself navigating unresolved grief, changing family relationships, and cherished traditions. When she reconnects with Sean, an unexpected connection and a misplaced engagement ring help Alyssa rediscover what matters most. 

Fun fact: The Christmas Yes List puts a festive spin on rejection therapy! Through Chloe's Christmas challenge to get comfortable hearing "no," she discovers that taking chances and embracing new experiences can lead to some wonderful surprises. 

Now, it’s time to find out where The Christmas Ring and An Ozark Mountain Christmas stand in the rankings! 

Rankings Reveal - Week Four 

1. Karen Kingsbury’s The Christmas Ring

Starring Jana Kramer, Ben Hollingsworth, Kelsey Grammer, Megan Ashley Brown and Jesse James Decker

Now streaming on Great American Pure Flix

A military widow’s search for her family’s treasured Christmas ring leads her to a widowed antiques dealer — and an unexpected second chance at love, healing, and a new beginning.

2. Silver Bells at Christmas

Starring Laura Osnes, Ryan McPartlin, Chuck Wicks, Julia Reilly, Tanya Christiansen, Taylor Kalupa, and D.B. Sweeney

Now streaming on Great American Pure Flix

When Ginny fights to save her late mother’s Christmas shop, an unexpected romance and the return of an old flame force her to choose between cherished traditions and new beginnings.

3. A Second Chance Christmas

Starring Candace Cameron Bure and Jonathan Scarfe

Now streaming on Great American Pure Flix

When an ice storm traps a divorced couple together at Christmas, old memories resurface and they discover that love may deserve a second chance.

5. An Ozark Mountain Christmas

Starring Jonathan Stoddard, Brianna Cohen, Julia Reilly, and Larry Parrish

Now streaming on Great American Pure Flix

When a driven young designer returns home to the Ozarks for Christmas, family traditions, faith, and an unexpected connection help her rediscover what matters most and find a renewed sense of purpose.

6. A Christmas Prayer Tradition

Starring Shae Robins, Christopher Russell and Madeleine Cox

Now streaming on Great American Pure Flix.

As a family embraces prayer and simple acts of kindness, a small town discovers the extraordinary ways faith can bring Christmas hope.

Up Next

The Christmas Yes List

Starring Danica McKellar and Sam Page

When Chloe returns home for Christmas, a holiday challenge pushes her beyond her comfort zone and toward an unexpected romance, renewed confidence, and faith in God’s timing.

Now streaming on Great American Pure Flix

Premiering on Great American Family November 14 at 8/7c.

Christmas at Moose Lake

Starring Britt Robertson and Ryan Paevey

When Alyssa returns to her family’s lake house for Christmas, an unexpected adventure and a new romance help her rediscover love, family, and the meaning of home.

Now Streaming on Great American Pure Flix

Premiering on Great American Family November 15 at 8/7c.

Tune in Wednesday, November 18th at 8 p.m. ET on Great American Pure Flix to see where The Christmas Yes List and Christmas at Moose Lake fall in the rankings, experience new conversations with talent, and enjoy an early screening one of our next premieres.

Where do your Great American Christmas Challenge rankings stand? Tell us below!